Experimenting Generalized Procrustes Analysis on a corpus of scenes carved on Mesopotamian cylinder seals and encoded in a textual data set
- Title
- Experimenting Generalized Procrustes Analysis on a corpus of scenes carved on Mesopotamian cylinder seals and encoded in a textual data set
- Creator(s)
- Di Ludovico, Alessandro
- Camiz, Sergio
- Date
- 2022
- Is Part Of
-
Archeologia e Calcolatori
- Volume
- 33
- Issue
- 2
- Pages
- 13-32
- Language
- eng
- Rights
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- Abstract
- In a recently published study, a textual dataset encoding a group of scenes depicted on Mesopotamian cylinder seals from the third millennium was submitted to Procrustes Analysis, considering Correspondence Analysis variations due to progressive reductions of the forms involved. The results seemed to indicate that a slight reduction in the number of forms used to describe the raw data would improve the Correspondence Analysis results. Indeed, the actual impact of each reduction on the outcome of the analyses could not be adequately identified if the forms were not considered as elements forming segments, i.e., sub-images of the scenes. In this paper, the results of the same methodology are presented, this time applied to repeated segments within the same dataset, i.e., sequences of textual forms that may describe sub-images of the described scenes. The comparison between the progressive reductions of repeated segments showed relevant differences between small (around 10% of the rarest segments) and large reductions. Indeed, the latter may undermine a consistent interpretation of the different finding sites, yet well represented keeping 90% of segments. Moreover, a reduction performed by hand and not on the frequency of occurrences provided better results.
- Cites
- Exploratory analysis of images engraved on ancient near-eastern seals based on a distance among strings
- Image study of Mesopotamian cylinder seals through texts: the Procrustes transformation applied to Correspondence Analysis results
- Éléments d'un modèle pour la description des lexiques documentaires
- Methods for the Descriptive Analysis of Archaeological Material
- Generalized procrustes analysis
- Four Codes for the Description of Artifacts: An Essay in Archeological Technique and Theory
- FactoMineR: An R Package for Multivariate Analysis
- Data Description and the Integrated Study of Ancient Near Eastern Works of Art: The Potential of Cylinder Seals
- Scene-in-frammenti: una proposta di analisi delle "scene di presentazione" dei sigilli a cilindro mesopotamici orientata all'elaborazione statistica ed informatica dei dati
- Spad.T – Version 1.5 – Manuel de référence
- Analyse statistique des données textuelles.Questions ouvertes et lexicométrie
- Die Einführungsszene: Entwicklung eines mesopotamischen Motivs von der altakkadischen bis zum Ende der altbabylonischen Zeit
- The King and the Cup: Iconography of the Royal Presentation Scene on Ur III Seals. Insight through Images: Studies in Honor of Edith Porada.
- Metodi di analisi per lo studio di un gruppo di sigilli cilindrici vicino-orientali e di altre immagini strutturate
- Exploratory analyses of structured images: a test on different coding procedures and analysis methods
- Analysis of ancient Near-Eastern cylinder seals (Late Fourth Millennium B.C.)
- On the coding of archaeological finds
- Procrustes Problems
- Reconstructing Lexicography in Glyptic Art: Structural Relations between the Akkadian age and the Ur III Period
- Art History of the Ancient Near East and Mathematical Models. An Overview
- Ancient Mesopotamian Glyptic Products, Statistics and Data Mining: A Research Proposal
- Legitimation of Authority Through Image and Legend: Seals Belonging to Officials in the Administrative Bureaucracy of the Ur 3. State
- Comparative Use of Mathematical Models in an Investigation on Mesopotamian Cylinder Seals
- Statistique textuelle
- A quantitative approach to Ur III Mesopotamian figurative languages: reflections, results, and new proposals
- R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing
- The Guttman effect: Its interpretation and a new redressing method
Export
Position: 3683 (7 views)